Hannah Spencer’s victory in the Gorton and Denton by-election is an extraordinary win for the Green Party and the implications should rock the political establishment in the UK.

While clearly demonstrating that the rise of the extreme right is not a foregone conclusion, and that an extreme left-wing party is a clear threat to a centrist Labour party, one other thing is obvious: politics is now more fragmented than at any time in recent history.
The reality is that 59% of voters did not vote for the winning candidate, and our first past the post (FPTP) electoral system means that the majority of voters are not represented in parliament. In the 2024 General Election, Labour won 63% of the seats in parliament on just 33.7% of the vote, so the majority of voters having no representation is not new, and is not unique to Gorton and Denton.
The Greens agree
Green Party policy is to support replacing the FPTP system for parliamentary elections with a fair and proportional voting system. That’s because they have repeatedly received disproportionately fewer seats relative to votes under FPTP: they won 6.7% of the vote but just 0.6% of the seats in the 2024 election.
Now they have tasted success with their first ever by-election victory under FPTP will they be tempted to soften or renege on their electoral policy?
Labour party members at their conference in 2022 expressed overwhelming support for the next Labour government to commit to delivering proportional representation (PR) for parliamentary elections. However, with Labour’s landslide victory in the 2024 General Election, a result of FPTP, there are no signs that the Labour government has any intention of implementing their member’s PR wishes.
Across Europe, the UK is the only country apart from tyrannical Belarus, to use FPTP in their parliamentary elections, all the others use some form of PR. Why? Because PR provides better representation for voters and “…on practically any measure of political stability, the stablest established democracies are users of PR”.
A PR system for the UK
PR takes many different forms across the world but in the UK the preferred form, as recommended by the Electoral Reform Society, is the single transferable vote. It’s a system that’s very simple for voters: rather than voting for a single candidate in a small constituency, you place in priority order (1, 2, 3, … or as many or as few as you like) a small group of candidates in a larger constituency who reflect the diversity of opinions in that local area.
The clever, and more complicated part, is what happens when votes are counted. A candidate in a constituency needs a set amount of votes, called a quota, to get elected. The quota is based on the total number of votes cast and the number of seats up for election. When your vote is counted, it goes to your number one candidate. However, if your number one choice has already exceeded the quota, and so has been elected, your vote is not wasted, but is moved to your second favourite candidate. This continues until all seats are filled.
This system means your vote is never wasted and representation in parliament is much more aligned with the diversity of voter opinion, while it still retains a strong element of local representation.
Why is the UK a FPTP outlier?
The Conservatives are staunch supporters of FPTP as made clear in their 2024 manifesto, and when campaigning to keep FPTP during the 2011 Alternative Vote referendum. Whereas the Liberal Democrats, Green Party, Reform UK, Plaid Cymru and the SNP all support a move to PR. So why are we still using FPTP?
The two-party system, whereby the Conservatives and Labour have been the only political parties to govern since 1922, was enabled by FPTP, a system that made it difficult for smaller parties to break through in any significant numbers. Since Labour and Conservatives were the only parties in power, they had little incentive for electoral reform. While they are winners under FPTP, why change?
Is change coming?
Could the fragmentation of UK politics, as seen in Gorton and Denton, be an early indicator that electoral reform may be a realistic possibility in the near future. Just look at the list of candidates in that by-election, and the range of opinions they represent, then consider a parliament where the 650 seats match that range of opinion. PR parties would be forced to work together, reach consensus views and co-operate over implementation. Extreme views would be unlikely to prevail, as demonstrated in the numerous coalition governments seen across Europe.
Alternatively, consider a parliament following a general election under FPTP, where the extreme right or left have a landslide victory. That would be taken as a mandate to implement whatever extreme policies they chose, and electors, most of whom probably did not vote for the winning party, would be unable to stop them.
By any rational consideration, it’s time the UK ditched FPTP and moved to PR.







