• Contact
  • About
  • Authors
DONATE
NEWSLETTER SIGN UP
  • Login
Central Bylines
  • Home
  • News
    • All
    • Brexit
    • Education
    • Environment
    • Health
    • Transport
    • World
    Air pollution

    Deadline extended for Government’s air pollution consultation

    Drunk Man

    Has the WHO allowed the drinks industry to water down its alcohol plan?

    The new Education White Paper - is it really ‘Opportunity for All’?

    The new Education White Paper – is it really ‘Opportunity for All’?

    Photo by Nik Shuliahin 💛💙 on Unsplash

    Mental Health Awareness Week: 9th-15th May

    London, England, UK - October 9, 2021: Protesters marched from Trafalgar Square to UK Parliament protesting the Northern Ireland Protocol demanding its cancellation.

    The NI Protocol and the Brexit ultras

    Adobe Stock licensed image by hanohiki

    Bad news for Newark: 110 jobs lost as town’s top employer withdraws to the EU 

    Photo by RODRIGO GONZALEZ on Unsplash

    The challenges faced by long covid sufferers as we “learn to live” with covid

    Benefits on the horizon?

    Brexit benefits: a reply to David Frost

    Photo Courtesy: U.S. Department of Energy's Atmospheric Radiation Measurement Program.

    Living on an island: the chequered history of offshore ‘people-management’

    Trending Tags

    • Johnson
    • Ukraine Conflict
    • Brexit
    • Education
    • Environment
    • Health
    • Transport
    • World
  • Politics
    Johnson

    Johnson’s Rwanda asylum scheme draws praise from fascists

    Statue of margeret Thatcher, Grantham

    Egg on their faces: Thatcher’s Grantham is a reminder of the division she helped create

    Image by Central Bylines Team

    The speed freak, law-breaking crime commissioner

    Image by Central Bylines Team

    Labour GAIN Allens Cross

    Photo by Roger Chapman on Unsplash

    Progressive gains resulting no overall control in Worcester

    London, England, UK - October 9, 2021: Protesters marched from Trafalgar Square to UK Parliament protesting the Northern Ireland Protocol demanding its cancellation.

    The NI Protocol and the Brexit ultras

    Official_portrait_of_Angela_Rayner_MP

    Angela Rayner has class, her attackers have none

    Despair

    Conservative council merger collapses over “irreconcilable differences”

    Author Mounsay

    Closing days of the local elections: what are the candidates saying in Allens Cross?

    Trending Tags

    • Levelling up
  • Opinion
    Adobe stock licensed image by Jorm S

    Freedom and conservatism

    This work is from the National Child Labor Committee collection at the Library of Congress. According to the library, there are no known copyright restrictions on the use of this work.

    Reflections on Boris Johnson’s ‘high skill, high wage future’ speech. Fashion – Fix up, look smart! 

    Adobe Stock licensed image by motortion

    Reflections on Boris Johnson’s ‘high skill, high wage future’ speech: the invisible half of the population

    Official United Kingdom Parliamentary photographs 2020 Tom Randall (politician) - CC-BY-3.0

    Why do people become MPs?

    Image by Central Bylines Team - derived from eligible Creative Commons sources

    Gaslighting an electorate – the moral bankruptcy of Edward Leigh 

    Adobe Stock licensed: Gibberish
by egokhan

    Lucy Allan talks gibberish

    Image by Number 10 for flickr licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 2.0

    Red wall voters to Johnson: in the name of God, go!

    Say no to the elections bill

    Say no to the Elections Bill

    Trending Tags

    • Lifestyle
      • All
      • Art
      • Books
      • Dance
      • Festivals
      • Fun & Games
      • Movies
      • Music
      • Poetry
      • Sport
      • Theatre
      • TV
      Euroscent

      Smells wonderful

      Britsh F1 Grand Prix 2021

      A winning formula? Why F2 champions may struggle to break into F1

      The Tooth Fairy

      Images by Dave Deans for Swan Theatre Company

      A good Egg: a preview of the play A Day in the Death of Joe Egg

      Author's own illustration

      The terrible fate of Charlie Bone

      Sam_Ryder

      A Spaceman went travelling

      Europe Day Poster

      Celebrating Europe day – concerts and rallies

      Shutterstock image (2137163653) by Serhii Mykhalchuk used under license

      What remains?

      This writer's life

      This Writer’s Life: a diary

      Trending Tags

        • Dance
        • Food
        • Music
        • Poetry
        • Recipes
        • Sport
      • Business
        • All
        • Economy
        • Technology
        • Trade
        Adobe Stock licensed image by hanohiki

        Bad news for Newark: 110 jobs lost as town’s top employer withdraws to the EU 

        Promotion image from Colleague Box website

        Pandemic start-up success story hampered by Brexit barriers

        Image licensed by Pixabay

        Information is power: its loss can be devastating

        Photo by Matt Bango on StockSnap

        Hassle in High Peak: Robert Largan’s solar farm shenanigans

        Adobe Stock licensed - image by blackday

        British Gas-lighting a nation: how energy companies are exploiting their customers with increased prices

        circular economy

        Reflections on Boris Johnson’s ‘high skill, high wage future’ speech

        Dog wrapped in a blanket, luckily he does not have to pay the bill.

        Fuel bills and service blunders as energy prices start to bite

        Picture of Darts board

        Reflections on Boris Johnson’s ‘high skill, high wage future’ speech

        Photo Bryan Manley-Green

        Exactly what does “Next” mean for E.on?

        Trending Tags

        • Levelling up
        • Economy
        • Technology
      • Region
        • All
        • East Midlands
        • West Midlands
        Vera Brittain plaque

        Midlands blue plaques part 1: Vera Brittain in Buxton

        Image by Central Bylines Team

        The speed freak, law-breaking crime commissioner

        Image by Central Bylines Team

        Labour GAIN Allens Cross

        Photo by Roger Chapman on Unsplash

        Progressive gains resulting no overall control in Worcester

        Valerii Semenov

        Chernobyl 27 April 2022

        Allens Cross Community Centre

        Allens Cross Community Association

        Despair

        Conservative council merger collapses over “irreconcilable differences”

        Author Mounsay

        Closing days of the local elections: what are the candidates saying in Allens Cross?

        What has my council done for me? Pt. 4: Crime & Anti-Social Behaviour

        What has my council done for me? Pt. 4: Crime & Anti-Social Behaviour

        Trending Tags

          • East Midlands
          • West Midlands
        • Events
        No Result
        View All Result
        • Home
        • News
          • All
          • Brexit
          • Education
          • Environment
          • Health
          • Transport
          • World
          Air pollution

          Deadline extended for Government’s air pollution consultation

          Drunk Man

          Has the WHO allowed the drinks industry to water down its alcohol plan?

          The new Education White Paper - is it really ‘Opportunity for All’?

          The new Education White Paper – is it really ‘Opportunity for All’?

          Photo by Nik Shuliahin 💛💙 on Unsplash

          Mental Health Awareness Week: 9th-15th May

          London, England, UK - October 9, 2021: Protesters marched from Trafalgar Square to UK Parliament protesting the Northern Ireland Protocol demanding its cancellation.

          The NI Protocol and the Brexit ultras

          Adobe Stock licensed image by hanohiki

          Bad news for Newark: 110 jobs lost as town’s top employer withdraws to the EU 

          Photo by RODRIGO GONZALEZ on Unsplash

          The challenges faced by long covid sufferers as we “learn to live” with covid

          Benefits on the horizon?

          Brexit benefits: a reply to David Frost

          Photo Courtesy: U.S. Department of Energy's Atmospheric Radiation Measurement Program.

          Living on an island: the chequered history of offshore ‘people-management’

          Trending Tags

          • Johnson
          • Ukraine Conflict
          • Brexit
          • Education
          • Environment
          • Health
          • Transport
          • World
        • Politics
          Johnson

          Johnson’s Rwanda asylum scheme draws praise from fascists

          Statue of margeret Thatcher, Grantham

          Egg on their faces: Thatcher’s Grantham is a reminder of the division she helped create

          Image by Central Bylines Team

          The speed freak, law-breaking crime commissioner

          Image by Central Bylines Team

          Labour GAIN Allens Cross

          Photo by Roger Chapman on Unsplash

          Progressive gains resulting no overall control in Worcester

          London, England, UK - October 9, 2021: Protesters marched from Trafalgar Square to UK Parliament protesting the Northern Ireland Protocol demanding its cancellation.

          The NI Protocol and the Brexit ultras

          Official_portrait_of_Angela_Rayner_MP

          Angela Rayner has class, her attackers have none

          Despair

          Conservative council merger collapses over “irreconcilable differences”

          Author Mounsay

          Closing days of the local elections: what are the candidates saying in Allens Cross?

          Trending Tags

          • Levelling up
        • Opinion
          Adobe stock licensed image by Jorm S

          Freedom and conservatism

          This work is from the National Child Labor Committee collection at the Library of Congress. According to the library, there are no known copyright restrictions on the use of this work.

          Reflections on Boris Johnson’s ‘high skill, high wage future’ speech. Fashion – Fix up, look smart! 

          Adobe Stock licensed image by motortion

          Reflections on Boris Johnson’s ‘high skill, high wage future’ speech: the invisible half of the population

          Official United Kingdom Parliamentary photographs 2020 Tom Randall (politician) - CC-BY-3.0

          Why do people become MPs?

          Image by Central Bylines Team - derived from eligible Creative Commons sources

          Gaslighting an electorate – the moral bankruptcy of Edward Leigh 

          Adobe Stock licensed: Gibberish
by egokhan

          Lucy Allan talks gibberish

          Image by Number 10 for flickr licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 2.0

          Red wall voters to Johnson: in the name of God, go!

          Say no to the elections bill

          Say no to the Elections Bill

          Trending Tags

          • Lifestyle
            • All
            • Art
            • Books
            • Dance
            • Festivals
            • Fun & Games
            • Movies
            • Music
            • Poetry
            • Sport
            • Theatre
            • TV
            Euroscent

            Smells wonderful

            Britsh F1 Grand Prix 2021

            A winning formula? Why F2 champions may struggle to break into F1

            The Tooth Fairy

            Images by Dave Deans for Swan Theatre Company

            A good Egg: a preview of the play A Day in the Death of Joe Egg

            Author's own illustration

            The terrible fate of Charlie Bone

            Sam_Ryder

            A Spaceman went travelling

            Europe Day Poster

            Celebrating Europe day – concerts and rallies

            Shutterstock image (2137163653) by Serhii Mykhalchuk used under license

            What remains?

            This writer's life

            This Writer’s Life: a diary

            Trending Tags

              • Dance
              • Food
              • Music
              • Poetry
              • Recipes
              • Sport
            • Business
              • All
              • Economy
              • Technology
              • Trade
              Adobe Stock licensed image by hanohiki

              Bad news for Newark: 110 jobs lost as town’s top employer withdraws to the EU 

              Promotion image from Colleague Box website

              Pandemic start-up success story hampered by Brexit barriers

              Image licensed by Pixabay

              Information is power: its loss can be devastating

              Photo by Matt Bango on StockSnap

              Hassle in High Peak: Robert Largan’s solar farm shenanigans

              Adobe Stock licensed - image by blackday

              British Gas-lighting a nation: how energy companies are exploiting their customers with increased prices

              circular economy

              Reflections on Boris Johnson’s ‘high skill, high wage future’ speech

              Dog wrapped in a blanket, luckily he does not have to pay the bill.

              Fuel bills and service blunders as energy prices start to bite

              Picture of Darts board

              Reflections on Boris Johnson’s ‘high skill, high wage future’ speech

              Photo Bryan Manley-Green

              Exactly what does “Next” mean for E.on?

              Trending Tags

              • Levelling up
              • Economy
              • Technology
            • Region
              • All
              • East Midlands
              • West Midlands
              Vera Brittain plaque

              Midlands blue plaques part 1: Vera Brittain in Buxton

              Image by Central Bylines Team

              The speed freak, law-breaking crime commissioner

              Image by Central Bylines Team

              Labour GAIN Allens Cross

              Photo by Roger Chapman on Unsplash

              Progressive gains resulting no overall control in Worcester

              Valerii Semenov

              Chernobyl 27 April 2022

              Allens Cross Community Centre

              Allens Cross Community Association

              Despair

              Conservative council merger collapses over “irreconcilable differences”

              Author Mounsay

              Closing days of the local elections: what are the candidates saying in Allens Cross?

              What has my council done for me? Pt. 4: Crime & Anti-Social Behaviour

              What has my council done for me? Pt. 4: Crime & Anti-Social Behaviour

              Trending Tags

                • East Midlands
                • West Midlands
              • Events
              No Result
              View All Result
              Central Bylines
              No Result
              View All Result
              Home UK

              Photographic Voter ID – A Very UnBritish Idea

              The Conservative government’s draft Elections Bill will require voters to prove their identity, ideally via a photographic ID.

              Professor Emeritus Edward Higgs by Professor Emeritus Edward Higgs
              18-09-2021 20:47
              in UK
              Photo by Ethan Wilkinson on Unsplash

              Photo by Ethan Wilkinson on Unsplash

              Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
              ADVERTISEMENT

              The Conservative government’s draft Elections Bill will require voters to prove their identity, ideally via a photographic ID. This will be required before receiving an electoral ballot paper and is a striking example of the recent tendency to assume that citizens are potentially untrustworthy.  It also shifts the onus to prove identification onto the individual via their relationship with the central state rather than the local community.  The paramount importance of the photograph is a departure from the historical norms of identification to establish rights in Britain.

              Identification rooted in the community

              Historically we, the British, have relied on our communities for identification. In the 19th century, when the concept of the electoral register was first introduced, it was not up to the individual registering to prove their identity or right to vote. Instead, the register was a public document. Others in the community could scrutinise it and then object to including an individual if they thought the latter did not have that right. 

              Similarly, when Old Age Pensions were first introduced in 1911, the elderly proved their identity via a recommendation from a local person of authority in the community.  After the First World War, the Treasury suggested fingerprinting all old-age pensioners for identification purposes. That imposition was opposed by the Ministry of Pensions and the War Office as ‘unBritish’, and as treating citizens as ‘criminals’.

              Photographs on documents were a particularly alien concept in more ways than one.  In 1835, the newly independent country of Belgium requested that ‘all foreign governments’ supply details such as age, height and hair colour on the passports they issued. In the resulting exchange, the then British Foreign Secretary Lord Palmerston described the passport system as ‘repugnant’ and the request for personal particulars ‘offensive and degrading’.  If the Belgians wanted to destroy their tourist industry, Palmerston thundered, that was their own choice.  A viewpoint that the current British administration would find incomprehensible.


              More from Central Bylines

              • What do you mean, Reboot GB?
              • Can a Trumpian Candidate Win the US Presidency in 2024?
              • There’s something about Nadine – Update

              Photographic passports introduced

              It was not until the First World War that the British began to issue passports with photographs. That was part of an international movement to regulate population movements during the shift to total warfare.  The British introduced passport photographs only in agreement with everyone else.

              But what they did not do was introduce photographs on internal documents.  Even during the two World Wars, identity documents held by most people did not contain a picture.  During the period 1939 to 1951, the only form of personal identification was a signature. Photographic driving licences did not appear until 1997 and only replaced the green paper licence in 2015.

              This avoidance of photographic ID did not apply to foreigners, or ‘aliens’ in the UK who had to carry photographic ID from 1914 onwards. The British also introduced photographic ID for Chinese ‘coolies’ working in the colonies. Then introduced them for South African labourers in mines in the early 20th century. They were mirroring other colonial powers, such as the French in Algiers and the Japanese in Taiwan.   Historically, photography was something the British did to non-citizens, either the foreigner in their midst or their ‘natives’ in the Empire.

              Identification no longer dependent upon community

              The government’s proposals in the 2021 Election Bill shift our context in the community to our recognition via centrally-created documents, such as passports and driving licences.  It is also a replacement of identification by personal recommendation or affirmation by identification via the body.

              Pandora’s box

              These changes are potentially moving us all into a world of digital identity at a time of rapidly-innovating facial recognition, data scraping, and artificial intelligence gathering, which could create digital profiles of us. Uncontrolled and unknown by many in the community, new forces are joining up data potentially to use it against us. African countries are already experimenting with facial recognition systems at the ballot box.  In the USA the police already have access to some 180 million driver’s license photographs which are being compared to criminal ID datasets via facial recognition.  The American police do not have to worry about the EU’s General Data Protection Regulation, which limits such use of personal images.  It is just this GDPR which the present government wishes to water down.  Like opening Pandora’s box, we do not know what these proposed changes will bring longer-term.

              Professor Emeritus Edward Higgs – author of Identifying the English and The Information State in England.  RebootGb member

              ADVERTISEMENT
              Previous Post

              Can a Trumpian Candidate Win the US Presidency in 2024?

              Next Post

              Shang-Chi movie review

              Professor Emeritus Edward Higgs

              Professor Emeritus Edward Higgs

              Related Posts

              Gates of Downing St
              Covid

              No excuses Boris. Most people obeyed  lockdown rules

              by Edward Cartwright
              24 April 2022
              Photo by RODRIGO GONZALEZ on Unsplash
              Covid

              The challenges faced by long covid sufferers as we “learn to live” with covid

              by Kelly Heath
              23 April 2022
              LFT positive test
              Covid

              Covid-19: millions of families lose their freedom as Boris Johnson gives some lives priority over others

              by June Roche
              7 March 2022
              Image by Number 10 for flickr licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 2.0
              Opinion

              Red wall voters to Johnson: in the name of God, go!

              by Central Bylines Team
              4 February 2022
              Author's own image
              A Cotswold Diary

              The Hillsborough disaster and the Sheldon Tapestries

              by Ann C Holland
              12 January 2022
              Next Post
              Shang-Chi

              Shang-Chi movie review

              Want to support us?

              Can you help Central Bylines to grow and become more sustainable with a regular donation, no matter how small?  

              DONATE

              Sign up to our newsletter

              If you would like to receive the Central Bylines regular newsletter, straight talking direct to your inbox, click the button below.

              NEWSLETTER

              LATEST

              Johnson

              Johnson’s Rwanda asylum scheme draws praise from fascists

              21 May 2022
              Air pollution

              Deadline extended for Government’s air pollution consultation

              20 May 2022
              Drunk Man

              Has the WHO allowed the drinks industry to water down its alcohol plan?

              20 May 2022
              Statue of margeret Thatcher, Grantham

              Egg on their faces: Thatcher’s Grantham is a reminder of the division she helped create

              19 May 2022

              MOST READ

              Statue of margeret Thatcher, Grantham

              Egg on their faces: Thatcher’s Grantham is a reminder of the division she helped create

              19 May 2022
              Johnson

              Johnson’s Rwanda asylum scheme draws praise from fascists

              21 May 2022
              Drunk Man

              Has the WHO allowed the drinks industry to water down its alcohol plan?

              20 May 2022
              Euroscent

              Smells wonderful

              19 May 2022

              BROWSE BY TAGS

              Blue Plaques Climate change Community Covid Energy Farming Johnson Latest Levelling up My Little Town Rwanda Ukraine Conflict Voting
              Central Bylines

              Central Bylines is a regional online newspaper that supports citizen journalism. Our aim is to publish well-written, fact-based articles and opinion pieces on subjects that are of interest to people in Central England and beyond.



              Learn more about us

              No Result
              View All Result
              • Contact
              • About
              • Donate
              • Privacy policy
              • Bylines network
              • Back Editions
              • Shop

              © 2022 Central Bylines. Citizen Journalism | Local & Internationalist

              No Result
              View All Result
              • Home
              • News
                • Brexit
                • Education
                • Environment
                • Health
                • Transport
                • World
              • Politics
              • Back in the news
              • Opinion
              • Lifestyle
                • Dance
                • Food
                • Music
                • Poetry
                • Recipes
                • Sport
              • Business
                • Economy
                • Technology
                • Trade
              • Regional Events
              • Donate
              • Newsletter sign up
              • A Cotswold Diary
              • Authors
              • BYLINES NETWORK
              • Contact

              © 2022 Central Bylines. Citizen Journalism | Local & Internationalist

              Welcome Back!

              Login to your account below

              Forgotten Password?

              Retrieve your password

              Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

              Log In
              X