Researchers have issued bespoke advice for drivers with obstructive sleep apnoea (OSA) after finding that common guidance for tackling tiredness behind the wheel may not be the most effective approach for people with the condition.
A simple ‘caffeine nap’ may need adjusting
Driver sleepiness contributes to a substantial proportion of road crashes. Drivers who begin to feel drowsy are often advised to stop, have a caffeinated drink and take a 15-minute nap – a combination known as a ‘caffeine nap’. It is designed to allow caffeine to take effect while the driver sleeps, helping them feel more alert when they wake up.
However, previous research supporting this advice has largely focused on the general population rather than people with OSA – the world’s most common sleep disorder, affecting an estimated one billion people globally. The condition causes repeated interruptions to breathing during sleep, which can affect both health and daytime alertness.
Study lead Professor Ashleigh Filtness, of Loughborough University’s Transport Safety Research Centre.
“Despite its prevalence, all previous research investigating how people manage driver sleepiness and evaluating methods to reduce sleepiness were conducted with participants without OSA.
We wanted to ensure the advice for people with obstructive sleep apnoea is based on evidence from people like them.”
Drivers with OSA need extra caffeine
The study, funded by The Road Safety Trust, involved 21 drivers with OSA who were receiving continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP) treatment – the most common treatment for the condition which uses a mask to keep the airway open during sleep.
Participants completed a series of driving simulator sessions after their sleep had been restricted to four hours. This duration was chosen because four hours of CPAP use per night is commonly used as the threshold for someone to be considered compliant with their prescribed treatment.
Researchers compared the effects of different amounts of caffeine, different nap lengths and caffeine naps on alertness and driving performance. To assess sleepiness, they monitored participants’ brain activity, eye movements and driving behaviour.
The team, who have published their findings in Nature’s Scientific Reports, found that two coffees significantly improved alertness and reduced driving errors compared with one.
Napping longer than 15 minutes has no extra benefits
The researchers observed no additional benefit from extending a nap from 15 to 30 minutes and modest improvements when a nap was added to two coffees.
Professor Fitlness explains:
The real-world higher consumption of caffeine in OSA drivers may explain why our study found two coffees to be most beneficial”, “Although we found that two coffees provided the greatest improvement in alertness, we would still encourage drivers to take a 15-minute nap if it is safe and practical to do so as there was some benefit for some people.
However, all countermeasures are temporary and cannot replace a good night of sleep before driving.
The researchers also found that participants showed signs of impaired driving after just four hours of sleep, which, they say, highlights that CPAP treatment compliance does not necessarily mean a person has had enough sleep to drive safely.
Four hours sleep at night causes driving impairment
Professor Filtness.:
It is important not to confuse being compliant with CPAP treatment with having had enough sleep to drive safely.
People with treated OSA were safe to drive when alert, but following sleep restriction to four hours, driving impairment was exhibited. OSA patients are encouraged to get as long a sleep as possible with CPAP and continue sleeping without CPAP if necessary.
To help translate the findings into practical guidance, the researchers have created an animated video and infographic explaining what drivers with obstructive sleep apnoea should do if they become sleepy while driving.
The advice is:
- Pull over at a service station
- Drink two iced coffees or an alternative caffeine source (250ml canned iced coffee is recommended because it provides a consistent caffeine dose and can be consumed quickly)
- Then nap for 15 minutes
- If time is short, consume two coffees and skip the nap.
Guidance for people with OSA to be updated
Professor Filtness is now working with clinicians, charities and road safety organisations – including The Road Safety Trust – to share the findings and improve guidance for people living with OSA.
Paul Steinberg, Deputy Chief Executive at The Road Safety Trust, said:
Funding research such as the Caffeine Nap study helps uncover hidden risks on our roads and provides practical, evidence-based solutions which could prevent death and serious injury.
We know that driver fatigue and drowsiness reduces concentration, impairs reaction times and can have very serious consequences. While a good night’s sleep is always the best preparation before driving, that is not always possible for people living with certain medical conditions or because of particular circumstances.
Professor Filtness and her team at Loughborough University have produced important new evidence and advice for drivers with obstructive sleep apnoea.
By supporting both research and practical guidance, the Trust is proud to fund projects which can help people make safer decisions to reduce risk on our roads.
The Loughborough researchers are hoping to build on the research by carrying out further studies into napping in vehicles to better understand how restorative sleep can be achieved during breaks.
The study, titled ‘Optimising the caffeine nap for counteracting driver sleepiness in CPAP treated obstructive sleep apnoea patients, can be read in full online.
The final project report can be found on The Road Safety Trust website.
Safety first
The government’s upcoming Online Safety Bill has been in the pipeline since 2019 but the murder of Southend MP, Sir...
The Flixborough disaster and its legacy for workplace safety
June 1974, an explosion at the Flixborough chemical plant killed 28 people. The Health and Safety at Work Act was...
Did Andy Burnham just ditch First-past-the-post?
Has the time for proportional representation finally arrived and what is driving electoral change forward?
Why young voices are missing from political debate
Young people are the workforce of tomorrow, yet their voices remain underrepresented in politics, why does democracy keep side-lining them?
Bylines Network & No One Above
Where is justice? Survivors voices in parliament
NOA and Bylines Network are collaborating to make sure those voices are heard by the decision-makers who can remove the roadblocks to justice and address systemic failures of accountability.
Your support will allow us to put Gazettes in the hands of all MPs and make the campaign visible around parliament.
