The idea that we all exist as fully independent individuals is plainly nonsensical. Whether it’s looking for a taller person to reach the top shelf in the supermarket, needing a second pair of hands to move a mattress, or getting advice on how to deal with a difficult social situation, we all depend on other people sometimes. The difference for disabled people who need care is only one of proportion. When you have a lot of support needs, however, getting on with day to day life without help can be impossible. So where do you turn?
Most people begin by doing what we all do first in that situation – asking family members and friends. This is how most people who become carers find themselves in that situation. Others have disabled children or grow up with a disabled parent and gradually take on a share of responsibility for caring. All of these people are known as kinship carers.
In all, there are five million kinship carers in England and Wales and almost 628,000 in Scotland. All of these people are doing their care work without receiving pay.
Care costs money
Being a kinship carer is expensive. Even if you are only doing a few hours a week, there’s an opportunity cost, especially if it’s hard to predict when you will be needed. Employers will be less willing to take you on, and if you’re in work when it starts, you risk missing out on promotional opportunities because you’re seen as unpredictable. Many carers have to cut their working hours, or can’t stay in employment at all. People who spend long periods providing care often find themselves treated as unemployable afterwards.
As a consequence of factors like these, 1.2 million carers are in poverty in the UK, with 400,000 in deep poverty (facing significant material deprivation). Almost half have cut back on essential things like heating, clothing, transport and even food. This is particularly worrying given that 30% of carers have disabilities of their own, making them more vulnerable to economic shock and increasing their daily living costs. This makes sense when you consider that disability becomes more common as we age, so many older people are caring for their partners as they too become infirm with the passing of time.
A fairer way forwards
When the state provides care, as is already the case for many (though not all) disabled people in Scotland, it isn’t inventing a new cost – it’s just redistributing an existing one. This makes life fairer, reducing the number of people who feel forced into providing care. It reduces the stress on everyone by making the prospect of oneself or a loved one becoming disabled less devastating, and it has a number of additional economic benefits.
Under a professionalised care system, money paid for care creates jobs and provides economic stimulus. People who would otherwise be providing kinship care are freed up to engage in paid work that utilises their talents and education. Furthermore, because professional carers can often fit around the schedules of the people they care for more easily than kinship carers, access to this type of care often makes it easier for disabled people themselves to work. All of these things result in increased tax revenues and less dependency on welfare payments.
Special cases
There are some situations in which professional care may not be the most practical option. If the person being cared for has a heavily suppressed immune system, for instance, it’s best to keep contacts to a minimum, so if somebody already living with that person is willing to do the work, that’s a safer approach. In Scotland, trade unions successfully argued that funding should not be available for any kind of care requiring manual lifting, in order to protect their members from a perceived risk of injury. This means that in situations where this cannot be worked around, disabled people need to pay for care themselves (as many carers still believe they can do some types of lifting safely) or, again, are dependent on those close to them. What can be done to make situations like this fairer?
If the government is smart about how it sets up its care system, cases like this will be on the radar from the outset. The lives of carers in these situations could be considerably improved by affording them professional recognition. This could come with training opportunities and appropriate certification. Done right, it would save the state money by reducing the number of instances in which external assistance was needed. It would mean that kinship carers no longer had gaps on their CVs, that their skills were properly recognised, and that they had the option of going on to do paid work for other people – which would also reduce the challenge of recruiting enough carers for the new system.
A positive approach to care
There will always be people who require care and it will always entail a cost, but that doesn’t mean we need to look at it in a negative way. When it is approached in a streamlined, professional way, damaging financial burdens are removed and economic potential revitalised. The risks of accident, burnout and abuse are all reduced, and disabled people gain more independence, including the freedom to make decisions about their relationships and living situations with the potential to result in mental health improvements. They are better able to participate in society and make use of their own talents and skills. As a result, everybody benefits.

Friends of Bylines Network
There has never been a greater need for grassroots journalism that investigates the stories that really matter, holds power to account and champions the voices of everyday citizens. We are proudly powered by volunteers but what we do isn’t free.
STAND WITH US for independent, citizen-led journalism that makes democracy stronger, and you will even get some exclusive benefits.







