SOS Biscathorpe
Lincolnshire Wolds, 14 July 2025. It’s hard to believe we’re here again. After a decade of battling to protect the Lincolnshire Wolds from an unwanted oil development, we’re now facing yet another round of public consultation and this time, the process seems more confusing than ever.
Publicity for the consultation has been left to the developer and it’s unclear how people are supposed to engage. The usual site notices are missing. People who previously objected haven’t been contacted. Confusion is understandably widespread. And the deadline for objections is 28 July 2025.
Lincolnshire bureaucracy trumps transparency
If you’ve somehow found out there’s a live application and visit Lincolnshire County Council’s planning portal (reference PL/0037/21-Appeals), you’ll find no mechanism for responding there. Instead, you have to go to the Planning Inspectorate’s website; this detail is buried in a document called ‘Press Notice June 2025’ near the bottom of a long list of 54 files on LCC’s portal. Don’t be misled by the one called ‘Planning Inspectorate contact details for submission of comments‘. It relates to a previous consultation and includes an incorrect email address.
Perhaps this isn’t a deliberate attempt to shut out public input, but it speaks volumes about a system where bureaucracy trumps transparency. It fails to reflect the spirit of the Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) Regulations, which clearly state that the public must be given early and effective opportunities to participate in environmental decision-making, especially on projects with major climate implications.
For those of us who have been campaigning with SOS Biscathorpe since the beginning, it’s exhausting. It should not fall to local residents to ensure a public consultation is actually public. That’s the job of government.
A High Court win, an appeal and new plans
Let’s rewind. Egdon Resources, an oil company, first applied in 2015 to explore for oil in one of the UK’s most beautiful and ecologically sensitive areas, the Lincolnshire Wolds National Landscape (formerly AONB), home to globally rare chalk streams.

Their 2019 drilling didn’t find viable reserves. But in 2021, Egdon came back with a new plan: sidetrack drilling, testing, and 15 years of full production. Lincolnshire County Council rightly refused it. Egdon appealed. A Planning Inspector overturned the decision in 2023 after a public hearing near Louth.
We challenged that in the High Court. And we won. In June 2024, the High Court quashed the Inspector’s decision for failing to assess the climate impact of downstream emissions (the carbon released when the oil is eventually burned). This followed the UK Supreme Court’s ‘Finch’ ruling, (the case of Finch vs Surrey County Council) which made clear that such emissions must be considered in planning decisions.

Ours is expected to be the first case to apply Finch in practice. The decision could shape how climate impacts are treated in planning across the UK.
Egdon response ignores the damage to rare and precious landscape
So how has Egdon responded? In new documents filed last month on the Lincolnshire County Council’s planning portal, they argue the emissions from burning 2.7 million barrels of oil are “insignificant”, yet they also claim this tiny oil volume is vital to UK energy security.
Let’s be clear: it would account for just 0.03% of UK annual oil consumption. That’s about 0.01% of UK energy consumption. A drop in the ocean at the cost of industrialising a protected landscape and threatening an irreplaceable chalk stream ecosystem. The plans even include discharging filtered surface water into local watercourses.
So we ask: is that really worth it?
Major development in a National Landscape has to be in the public interest to be allowed. We believe that, in a climate crisis, every tonne of greenhouse gas matters. And every decision we make now should reflect the future we want to build for younger generations, not chain us to a fossil-fuelled past.
Egdon’s parent company, by the way, is Heyco Energy, a US-based oil firm with fracking interests. Their profits won’t stay in Lincolnshire, but the damage they leave behind might.
Urgent – have your say
We’re urging the Planning Inspectorate to hold a public hearing or Inquiry. The Finch ruling underlines the need for strong public participation in climate-related decisions. This is exactly such a case.
So if you care about the Wolds, about fairness, about climate justice, please submit your comments before the deadline of 28 July 2025. Let’s show them that Lincolnshire is watching — and we won’t let this slip through quietly.
Visit the Planning inspectorate website and search for Appeal Reference 3296831.
To support the work of SOS Biscathorpe, please visit our fundraiser and/or follow us on Facebook.







