• Contact
  • About
  • Authors
DONATE
NEWSLETTER SIGN UP
  • Login
Central Bylines
  • Home
  • News
    • All
    • Brexit
    • Education
    • Environment
    • Health
    • Transport
    • World
    Bruce Kent at a Stop Trident rally

    Bruce Kent (1929 – 2022) – a personal view

    Factory

    Cutting emissions from construction and automotive materials by a third

    child labour

    World losing fight to end child labour

    Protester and injunction

    Jesus wept: meet Mark Coleman, retired vicar and Just Stop Oil activist

    Cotton mill

    Gardens of the revolution: Fashion revolution at the Chelsea flower show

    Flowers

    This writer’s life: a diary. Part 3: Garden blessings

    Vigil for Visas

    Vigil for Visas: delays in issuing visas to refugees from the war in Ukraine cause misery and fear

    The motherland calls

    Your Deed Is Immortal: Russia’s obsession with her WWII past and her war against Ukraine

    Air pollution

    Deadline extended for Government’s air pollution consultation

    Trending Tags

    • Johnson
    • Ukraine Conflict
    • Brexit
    • Education
    • Environment
    • Health
    • Transport
    • World
  • Politics
    Patriotism in the UK

    Johnson isn’t a patriot, he’s a pariah

    Return to imperial measures

    The return of imperial measurements?

    Gun Control

    ‘Gun Free Zone’ (a ‘Found’ poem, extracted from Trump’s NRA conference speech in Houston, a few days later)

    Statue of a bishop

    Johnson can’t govern so he lies instead

    Fraud and government schemes

    Fraud and government schemes

    East midlands greatest hits

    East Midlands Conservative greatest hits, Spring 2022

    Voting

    Boris Johnson won’t remove himself – we all have to help

    Anti-rascism protest

    Anti-racism campaigners in Stoke-on-Trent demand change

    Johnson

    Johnson’s Rwanda asylum scheme draws praise from fascists

    Trending Tags

    • Levelling up
  • Opinion
    Adobe stock licensed image by Jorm S

    Freedom and conservatism

    This work is from the National Child Labor Committee collection at the Library of Congress. According to the library, there are no known copyright restrictions on the use of this work.

    Reflections on Boris Johnson’s ‘high skill, high wage future’ speech. Fashion – Fix up, look smart! 

    Adobe Stock licensed image by motortion

    Reflections on Boris Johnson’s ‘high skill, high wage future’ speech: the invisible half of the population

    Official United Kingdom Parliamentary photographs 2020 Tom Randall (politician) - CC-BY-3.0

    Why do people become MPs?

    Image by Central Bylines Team - derived from eligible Creative Commons sources

    Gaslighting an electorate – the moral bankruptcy of Edward Leigh 

    Adobe Stock licensed: Gibberish
by egokhan

    Lucy Allan talks gibberish

    Image by Number 10 for flickr licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 2.0

    Red wall voters to Johnson: in the name of God, go!

    Say no to the elections bill

    Say no to the Elections Bill

    Trending Tags

    • Lifestyle
      • All
      • Art
      • Books
      • Dance
      • Festivals
      • Fun & Games
      • Movies
      • Music
      • Poetry
      • Sport
      • Theatre
      • TV
      Image by author

      Anne Boleyn

      Portrait of William Byrd by The Trustees of the British Museum ©, licensed by CC BY-NC-SA 4.0

      William Byrd – “a Father of Musick”

      Waverly community garden

      Launch of Better Together Community Garden in Clayton

      Illustration by AB Wyze

      Here I’m sat

      Liverpool in Paris

      Gun Control

      ‘Gun Free Zone’ (a ‘Found’ poem, extracted from Trump’s NRA conference speech in Houston, a few days later)

      Bally Gill, David Morrissey, James Graham and Joanne Froggatt - sherwood cast

      Sherwood: what lies beneath?

      O'Rourke

      O’Rourke

      Fighter,Pilots,Cockpit,View,Under,Cloudy,Blue,Sky

      Top Gun, I feel the need…..

      Trending Tags

        • Dance
        • Food
        • Music
        • Poetry
        • Recipes
        • Sport
      • Business
        • All
        • Economy
        • Technology
        • Trade
        cloudy beer

        UK’s first cloudy beer

        Cost of living crisis

        Crisis? What crisis? The cost of living crisis and political responses

        Adobe Stock licensed image by hanohiki

        Bad news for Newark: 110 jobs lost as town’s top employer withdraws to the EU 

        Promotion image from Colleague Box website

        Pandemic start-up success story hampered by Brexit barriers

        Image licensed by Pixabay

        Information is power: its loss can be devastating

        Photo by Matt Bango on StockSnap

        Hassle in High Peak: Robert Largan’s solar farm shenanigans

        Adobe Stock licensed - image by blackday

        British Gas-lighting a nation: how energy companies are exploiting their customers with increased prices

        circular economy

        Reflections on Boris Johnson’s ‘high skill, high wage future’ speech

        Dog wrapped in a blanket, luckily he does not have to pay the bill.

        Fuel bills and service blunders as energy prices start to bite

        Trending Tags

        • Levelling up
        • Economy
        • Technology
      • Region
        • All
        • East Midlands
        • West Midlands
        Image by Number 10 used under CC2 - Prime Minister Boris Johnson met Irish Taoiseach Leo Varadkar on 10 October 2019 to discuss the UK's Brexit proposals.

        The Northern Ireland protocol

        Waverly community garden

        Launch of Better Together Community Garden in Clayton

        Rent seeking

        A ‘high skill, high wage future’? Rentier Capitalism: who owns the future?

        Liverpool in Paris

        Mark Serwotka

        Trades Unionists demand action on the cost of living crisis at rally in Stoke-on-Trent

        East midlands greatest hits

        East Midlands Conservative greatest hits, Spring 2022

        Allens Cross Community Centre

        St Bart’s Pantry, open for business!

        women in power 2

        Women in power

        Vera Brittain plaque

        Midlands blue plaques part 1: Vera Brittain in Buxton

        Trending Tags

          • East Midlands
          • West Midlands
        • Events
        No Result
        View All Result
        • Home
        • News
          • All
          • Brexit
          • Education
          • Environment
          • Health
          • Transport
          • World
          Bruce Kent at a Stop Trident rally

          Bruce Kent (1929 – 2022) – a personal view

          Factory

          Cutting emissions from construction and automotive materials by a third

          child labour

          World losing fight to end child labour

          Protester and injunction

          Jesus wept: meet Mark Coleman, retired vicar and Just Stop Oil activist

          Cotton mill

          Gardens of the revolution: Fashion revolution at the Chelsea flower show

          Flowers

          This writer’s life: a diary. Part 3: Garden blessings

          Vigil for Visas

          Vigil for Visas: delays in issuing visas to refugees from the war in Ukraine cause misery and fear

          The motherland calls

          Your Deed Is Immortal: Russia’s obsession with her WWII past and her war against Ukraine

          Air pollution

          Deadline extended for Government’s air pollution consultation

          Trending Tags

          • Johnson
          • Ukraine Conflict
          • Brexit
          • Education
          • Environment
          • Health
          • Transport
          • World
        • Politics
          Patriotism in the UK

          Johnson isn’t a patriot, he’s a pariah

          Return to imperial measures

          The return of imperial measurements?

          Gun Control

          ‘Gun Free Zone’ (a ‘Found’ poem, extracted from Trump’s NRA conference speech in Houston, a few days later)

          Statue of a bishop

          Johnson can’t govern so he lies instead

          Fraud and government schemes

          Fraud and government schemes

          East midlands greatest hits

          East Midlands Conservative greatest hits, Spring 2022

          Voting

          Boris Johnson won’t remove himself – we all have to help

          Anti-rascism protest

          Anti-racism campaigners in Stoke-on-Trent demand change

          Johnson

          Johnson’s Rwanda asylum scheme draws praise from fascists

          Trending Tags

          • Levelling up
        • Opinion
          Adobe stock licensed image by Jorm S

          Freedom and conservatism

          This work is from the National Child Labor Committee collection at the Library of Congress. According to the library, there are no known copyright restrictions on the use of this work.

          Reflections on Boris Johnson’s ‘high skill, high wage future’ speech. Fashion – Fix up, look smart! 

          Adobe Stock licensed image by motortion

          Reflections on Boris Johnson’s ‘high skill, high wage future’ speech: the invisible half of the population

          Official United Kingdom Parliamentary photographs 2020 Tom Randall (politician) - CC-BY-3.0

          Why do people become MPs?

          Image by Central Bylines Team - derived from eligible Creative Commons sources

          Gaslighting an electorate – the moral bankruptcy of Edward Leigh 

          Adobe Stock licensed: Gibberish
by egokhan

          Lucy Allan talks gibberish

          Image by Number 10 for flickr licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 2.0

          Red wall voters to Johnson: in the name of God, go!

          Say no to the elections bill

          Say no to the Elections Bill

          Trending Tags

          • Lifestyle
            • All
            • Art
            • Books
            • Dance
            • Festivals
            • Fun & Games
            • Movies
            • Music
            • Poetry
            • Sport
            • Theatre
            • TV
            Image by author

            Anne Boleyn

            Portrait of William Byrd by The Trustees of the British Museum ©, licensed by CC BY-NC-SA 4.0

            William Byrd – “a Father of Musick”

            Waverly community garden

            Launch of Better Together Community Garden in Clayton

            Illustration by AB Wyze

            Here I’m sat

            Liverpool in Paris

            Gun Control

            ‘Gun Free Zone’ (a ‘Found’ poem, extracted from Trump’s NRA conference speech in Houston, a few days later)

            Bally Gill, David Morrissey, James Graham and Joanne Froggatt - sherwood cast

            Sherwood: what lies beneath?

            O'Rourke

            O’Rourke

            Fighter,Pilots,Cockpit,View,Under,Cloudy,Blue,Sky

            Top Gun, I feel the need…..

            Trending Tags

              • Dance
              • Food
              • Music
              • Poetry
              • Recipes
              • Sport
            • Business
              • All
              • Economy
              • Technology
              • Trade
              cloudy beer

              UK’s first cloudy beer

              Cost of living crisis

              Crisis? What crisis? The cost of living crisis and political responses

              Adobe Stock licensed image by hanohiki

              Bad news for Newark: 110 jobs lost as town’s top employer withdraws to the EU 

              Promotion image from Colleague Box website

              Pandemic start-up success story hampered by Brexit barriers

              Image licensed by Pixabay

              Information is power: its loss can be devastating

              Photo by Matt Bango on StockSnap

              Hassle in High Peak: Robert Largan’s solar farm shenanigans

              Adobe Stock licensed - image by blackday

              British Gas-lighting a nation: how energy companies are exploiting their customers with increased prices

              circular economy

              Reflections on Boris Johnson’s ‘high skill, high wage future’ speech

              Dog wrapped in a blanket, luckily he does not have to pay the bill.

              Fuel bills and service blunders as energy prices start to bite

              Trending Tags

              • Levelling up
              • Economy
              • Technology
            • Region
              • All
              • East Midlands
              • West Midlands
              Image by Number 10 used under CC2 - Prime Minister Boris Johnson met Irish Taoiseach Leo Varadkar on 10 October 2019 to discuss the UK's Brexit proposals.

              The Northern Ireland protocol

              Waverly community garden

              Launch of Better Together Community Garden in Clayton

              Rent seeking

              A ‘high skill, high wage future’? Rentier Capitalism: who owns the future?

              Liverpool in Paris

              Mark Serwotka

              Trades Unionists demand action on the cost of living crisis at rally in Stoke-on-Trent

              East midlands greatest hits

              East Midlands Conservative greatest hits, Spring 2022

              Allens Cross Community Centre

              St Bart’s Pantry, open for business!

              women in power 2

              Women in power

              Vera Brittain plaque

              Midlands blue plaques part 1: Vera Brittain in Buxton

              Trending Tags

                • East Midlands
                • West Midlands
              • Events
              No Result
              View All Result
              Central Bylines
              No Result
              View All Result
              Home Politics

              In terms of the monarchy, there is a way we can have our cake and eat it

              Our monarchy is antiquated and undemocratic, with a pure accident of blood leading to you being given a life of privilege and entitlement. These are arguably also its greatest strengths.

              Stewart TolleybyStewart Tolley
              15-03-2021 10:07
              in Politics, UK
              Photo: John King

              Photo: John King

              Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
              ADVERTISEMENT

              It has not come as a surprise but with the recent revelations about the monarchy, the republicans are having a field day.  #Abolish the Monarchy soon began to trend on twitter. Republic, the main lobby group for UK republicans tweeted with glee:

              “The monarchy has just been hit by its worst crisis since the abdication in 1936. Whether for the sake of Britain or for the sake of the younger royals this rotten institution needs to go. #AbolishTheMonarchy”.

              Now this statement may well be slight hyperbole on their part but it does strike at some definite truths about our current monarchy, it is antiquated and undemocratic, with a pure accident of blood leading to you being given a life of privilege and entitlement. These are arguably also its greatest strengths.

              There may be many like me who have no love or loyalty to the House of Windsor but love and respect constitutional monarchy as an institution and see its advantages. It is clear that many of the top progressive countries, Sweden, Norway, Denmark and the Netherlands are constitutional monarchies. It has been even argued that such institutions act as ‘aids to democracy’.

              The Queen is tremendously popular, with an almost 80 per cent approval rating, something any politician would kill for. That said, Prince Charles, the heir to the throne is certainly not in the same league, in the same poll he dips below 50 per cent.

              The problem is that there is arguably no decent alternative for those like me who are uncomfortable with a Presidency. There are two types and both in my mind are inadequate. Firstly, there is an elected executive President with powers (think USA/France). This is not a good route to go down as these figures are always partisan, heavily political, divisive and biased, not creating a figure ‘above politics’ like a monarchy does.

              Secondly, there are the glorified elected ribbon cutters. The Ireland, Germany, Italy model where no one actually knows who the head of state is. They are also nearly always former elected politicians even if they have to govern as nominal independents. This is preferable to the executive president but still lacks the one important thing a monarchy brings, which is the hard to define ‘majesty’. This is the pomp and pageantry that evoke centuries of tradition and give people a sense of pride in nation. This should not be dismissed, it is very important culturally.

              So is there a third way? A head of state that could satisfy republicans and monarchists?  Arguably there is. This is to replace the hereditary monarchy with an elected monarchy. This is not as crazy or as oxymoronic as it sounds, Poland saw a range of different figures, including Swedes, Germans and Frenchmen elected to the throne of the Polish Lithuanian Commonwealth. The Vatican still does this, and it was the principal means of appointing the Doges of Venice for centuries. There is  an ancient English precedent as well. The Witenagemot (or Witan) had a role in choosing which member of the royal family they wanted to be their ruler and occasionally by-passed formal primogeniture rules or acted as arbiters during disputed successions. They confirmed Alfred the Great over his nephews for instance and decided on Harold Godwinson as King.

              Now to retain the non-political nature and majesty of monarchy, any modern Witan must itself be non-political. Luckily we have a ready made version in the House of Lords. I have always been against an elected Lords, not because I am against democracy but because the idea of a chamber full of more failed party politicians is not going to improve anything. We lose the expertise and service of many cross-benchers who make such a contribution to this  unique chamber.


              More from Central Bylines

              • Whisper who dares
              • Here’s to an Independent Scotland
              • The conversation men should have with each other

              What does need changing is access. We need to make sure that appointments are taken away from the Prime Minister and that the vast majority of people appointed to the Lords are non-political, perhaps through quotas of professions (lawyers, doctors, architects etc) and a certain number of elected ‘ordinary’ people (perhaps nominated by local councils for their service to the community). This would create two types of lord: ‘Witan Lords’ and ‘Political Lords’.

              This improved “selectorate” of crossbenchers would therefore be perfect to choose a monarch from amongst its numbers. The only qualification to be a member of the Witan would be that you must not have been a politician or have held a formal political affiliation. So there is no worry about a former Prime Minister coming back as head of state. The ‘political lords’ would probably remain and they may vote on selection but they couldn’t themselves be elected. Now either this Witan would choose the final candidate or perhaps two who would then get confirmed by the people in a popular vote for further accountability.

              The new monarch would be still addressed in royal terms and retain the title, they would have an investiture with all the pomp and ceremony of a coronation. They would reign until they died or abdicated (abdication would I suspect be the more common) and these selections would themselves become part of our cultural fabric. They would also be selected from and by those who have been rewarded for expertise and service and furthermore be accountable to the people. A happy compromise I believe for all.

              ADVERTISEMENT
              Previous Post

              The conversation men should have with each other

              Next Post

              Don’t let the Tories stop dissent

              Stewart Tolley

              Stewart Tolley

              Related Posts

              Patriotism in the UK
              Politics

              Johnson isn’t a patriot, he’s a pariah

              byMike Stafford
              24 June 2022
              Return to imperial measures
              Politics

              The return of imperial measurements?

              byPippa Musgrave
              17 June 2022
              Gun Control
              Poetry

              ‘Gun Free Zone’ (a ‘Found’ poem, extracted from Trump’s NRA conference speech in Houston, a few days later)

              byLynda Tavakoli
              16 June 2022
              Statue of a bishop
              Politics

              Johnson can’t govern so he lies instead

              byMike Stafford
              8 June 2022
              Fraud and government schemes
              Politics

              Fraud and government schemes

              byPenny Lane
              7 June 2022
              Next Post
              "Inspirational young speakers at the Black Lives Matter Sheffield protest 2020" by Tim Dennell is licensed under CC BY-NC 2.0

              Don't let the Tories stop dissent

              Want to support us?

              Can you help Central Bylines to grow and become more sustainable with a regular donation, no matter how small?  

              DONATE

              Sign up to our newsletter

              If you would like to receive the Central Bylines regular newsletter, straight talking direct to your inbox, click the button below.

              NEWSLETTER

              LATEST

              Image by Number 10 used under CC2 - Prime Minister Boris Johnson met Irish Taoiseach Leo Varadkar on 10 October 2019 to discuss the UK's Brexit proposals.

              The Northern Ireland protocol

              27 June 2022
              Image by author

              Anne Boleyn

              27 June 2022
              Bruce Kent at a Stop Trident rally

              Bruce Kent (1929 – 2022) – a personal view

              27 June 2022
              Portrait of William Byrd by The Trustees of the British Museum ©, licensed by CC BY-NC-SA 4.0

              William Byrd – “a Father of Musick”

              25 June 2022

              MOST READ

              Patriotism in the UK

              Johnson isn’t a patriot, he’s a pariah

              24 June 2022
              Lee Anderson

              Keeping up with Lee Anderson

              21 June 2021
              Bruce Kent at a Stop Trident rally

              Bruce Kent (1929 – 2022) – a personal view

              27 June 2022
              Image by Number 10 used under CC2 - Prime Minister Boris Johnson met Irish Taoiseach Leo Varadkar on 10 October 2019 to discuss the UK's Brexit proposals.

              The Northern Ireland protocol

              27 June 2022

              BROWSE BY TAGS

              Blue Plaques Climate change Community Cost of living crisis Covid Energy Farming Johnson Latest Levelling up My Little Town Rwanda Ukraine Conflict Voting Whistleblower
              Central Bylines

              Central Bylines is a regional online newspaper that supports citizen journalism. Our aim is to publish well-written, fact-based articles and opinion pieces on subjects that are of interest to people in Central England and beyond.



              Learn more about us

              No Result
              View All Result
              • Contact
              • About
              • Donate
              • Privacy policy
              • Bylines network
              • Back Editions
              • Shop

              © 2022 Central Bylines. Citizen Journalism | Local & Internationalist

              No Result
              View All Result
              • Home
              • News
                • Brexit
                • Education
                • Environment
                • Health
                • Transport
                • World
              • Politics
              • Back in the news
              • Opinion
              • Lifestyle
                • Dance
                • Food
                • Music
                • Poetry
                • Recipes
                • Sport
              • Business
                • Economy
                • Technology
                • Trade
              • Regional Events
              • Donate
              • Newsletter sign up
              • A Cotswold Diary
              • Authors
              • BYLINES NETWORK
              • Contact

              © 2022 Central Bylines. Citizen Journalism | Local & Internationalist

              Welcome Back!

              Login to your account below

              Forgotten Password?

              Retrieve your password

              Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

              Log In
              X