• Contact
  • About
  • Authors
DONATE
NEWSLETTER SIGN UP
  • Login
Central Bylines
  • Home
  • News
    • All
    • Brexit
    • Education
    • Environment
    • Health
    • Transport
    • World
    Protester

    Roe v Wade: men benefit from abortion rights too – and should speak about them more

    Bruce Kent at a Stop Trident rally

    Bruce Kent (1929 – 2022) – a personal view

    Factory

    Cutting emissions from construction and automotive materials by a third

    child labour

    World losing fight to end child labour

    Protester and injunction

    Jesus wept: meet Mark Coleman, retired vicar and Just Stop Oil activist

    Cotton mill

    Gardens of the revolution: Fashion revolution at the Chelsea flower show

    Flowers

    This writer’s life: a diary. Part 3: Garden blessings

    Vigil for Visas

    Vigil for Visas: delays in issuing visas to refugees from the war in Ukraine cause misery and fear

    The motherland calls

    Your Deed Is Immortal: Russia’s obsession with her WWII past and her war against Ukraine

    Trending Tags

    • Johnson
    • Ukraine Conflict
    • Brexit
    • Education
    • Environment
    • Health
    • Transport
    • World
  • Politics
    Power to the people

    Power to the people

    Patriotism in the UK

    Johnson isn’t a patriot, he’s a pariah

    Return to imperial measures

    The return of imperial measurements?

    Gun Control

    ‘Gun Free Zone’ (a ‘Found’ poem, extracted from Trump’s NRA conference speech in Houston, a few days later)

    Statue of a bishop

    Johnson can’t govern so he lies instead

    Fraud and government schemes

    Fraud and government schemes

    East midlands greatest hits

    East Midlands Conservative greatest hits, Spring 2022

    Voting

    Boris Johnson won’t remove himself – we all have to help

    Anti-rascism protest

    Anti-racism campaigners in Stoke-on-Trent demand change

    Trending Tags

    • Levelling up
  • Opinion
    Adobe stock licensed image by Jorm S

    Freedom and conservatism

    This work is from the National Child Labor Committee collection at the Library of Congress. According to the library, there are no known copyright restrictions on the use of this work.

    Reflections on Boris Johnson’s ‘high skill, high wage future’ speech. Fashion – Fix up, look smart! 

    Adobe Stock licensed image by motortion

    Reflections on Boris Johnson’s ‘high skill, high wage future’ speech: the invisible half of the population

    Official United Kingdom Parliamentary photographs 2020 Tom Randall (politician) - CC-BY-3.0

    Why do people become MPs?

    Image by Central Bylines Team - derived from eligible Creative Commons sources

    Gaslighting an electorate – the moral bankruptcy of Edward Leigh 

    Adobe Stock licensed: Gibberish
by egokhan

    Lucy Allan talks gibberish

    Image by Number 10 for flickr licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 2.0

    Red wall voters to Johnson: in the name of God, go!

    Say no to the elections bill

    Say no to the Elections Bill

    Trending Tags

    • Lifestyle
      • All
      • Art
      • Books
      • Dance
      • Festivals
      • Fun & Games
      • Movies
      • Music
      • Poetry
      • Sport
      • Theatre
      • TV
      Image by author

      Anne Boleyn

      Portrait of William Byrd by The Trustees of the British Museum ©, licensed by CC BY-NC-SA 4.0

      William Byrd – “a Father of Musick”

      Waverly community garden

      Launch of Better Together Community Garden in Clayton

      Illustration by AB Wyze

      Here I’m sat

      Liverpool in Paris

      Gun Control

      ‘Gun Free Zone’ (a ‘Found’ poem, extracted from Trump’s NRA conference speech in Houston, a few days later)

      Bally Gill, David Morrissey, James Graham and Joanne Froggatt - sherwood cast

      Sherwood: what lies beneath?

      O'Rourke

      O’Rourke

      Fighter,Pilots,Cockpit,View,Under,Cloudy,Blue,Sky

      Top Gun, I feel the need…..

      Trending Tags

        • Dance
        • Food
        • Music
        • Poetry
        • Recipes
        • Sport
      • Business
        • All
        • Economy
        • Technology
        • Trade
        cloudy beer

        UK’s first cloudy beer

        Cost of living crisis

        Crisis? What crisis? The cost of living crisis and political responses

        Adobe Stock licensed image by hanohiki

        Bad news for Newark: 110 jobs lost as town’s top employer withdraws to the EU 

        Promotion image from Colleague Box website

        Pandemic start-up success story hampered by Brexit barriers

        Image licensed by Pixabay

        Information is power: its loss can be devastating

        Photo by Matt Bango on StockSnap

        Hassle in High Peak: Robert Largan’s solar farm shenanigans

        Adobe Stock licensed - image by blackday

        British Gas-lighting a nation: how energy companies are exploiting their customers with increased prices

        circular economy

        Reflections on Boris Johnson’s ‘high skill, high wage future’ speech

        Dog wrapped in a blanket, luckily he does not have to pay the bill.

        Fuel bills and service blunders as energy prices start to bite

        Trending Tags

        • Levelling up
        • Economy
        • Technology
      • Region
        • All
        • East Midlands
        • West Midlands
        Image by Number 10 used under CC2 - Prime Minister Boris Johnson met Irish Taoiseach Leo Varadkar on 10 October 2019 to discuss the UK's Brexit proposals.

        The Northern Ireland protocol

        Waverly community garden

        Launch of Better Together Community Garden in Clayton

        Rent seeking

        A ‘high skill, high wage future’? Rentier capitalism: who owns the future?

        Liverpool in Paris

        Mark Serwotka

        Trades unionists demand action on the cost-of-living crisis at rally in Stoke-on-Trent

        East midlands greatest hits

        East Midlands Conservative greatest hits, Spring 2022

        Allens Cross Community Centre

        St Bart’s Pantry, open for business!

        women in power 2

        Women in power

        Vera Brittain plaque

        Midlands blue plaques part 1: Vera Brittain in Buxton

        Trending Tags

          • East Midlands
          • West Midlands
        • Events
        No Result
        View All Result
        • Home
        • News
          • All
          • Brexit
          • Education
          • Environment
          • Health
          • Transport
          • World
          Protester

          Roe v Wade: men benefit from abortion rights too – and should speak about them more

          Bruce Kent at a Stop Trident rally

          Bruce Kent (1929 – 2022) – a personal view

          Factory

          Cutting emissions from construction and automotive materials by a third

          child labour

          World losing fight to end child labour

          Protester and injunction

          Jesus wept: meet Mark Coleman, retired vicar and Just Stop Oil activist

          Cotton mill

          Gardens of the revolution: Fashion revolution at the Chelsea flower show

          Flowers

          This writer’s life: a diary. Part 3: Garden blessings

          Vigil for Visas

          Vigil for Visas: delays in issuing visas to refugees from the war in Ukraine cause misery and fear

          The motherland calls

          Your Deed Is Immortal: Russia’s obsession with her WWII past and her war against Ukraine

          Trending Tags

          • Johnson
          • Ukraine Conflict
          • Brexit
          • Education
          • Environment
          • Health
          • Transport
          • World
        • Politics
          Power to the people

          Power to the people

          Patriotism in the UK

          Johnson isn’t a patriot, he’s a pariah

          Return to imperial measures

          The return of imperial measurements?

          Gun Control

          ‘Gun Free Zone’ (a ‘Found’ poem, extracted from Trump’s NRA conference speech in Houston, a few days later)

          Statue of a bishop

          Johnson can’t govern so he lies instead

          Fraud and government schemes

          Fraud and government schemes

          East midlands greatest hits

          East Midlands Conservative greatest hits, Spring 2022

          Voting

          Boris Johnson won’t remove himself – we all have to help

          Anti-rascism protest

          Anti-racism campaigners in Stoke-on-Trent demand change

          Trending Tags

          • Levelling up
        • Opinion
          Adobe stock licensed image by Jorm S

          Freedom and conservatism

          This work is from the National Child Labor Committee collection at the Library of Congress. According to the library, there are no known copyright restrictions on the use of this work.

          Reflections on Boris Johnson’s ‘high skill, high wage future’ speech. Fashion – Fix up, look smart! 

          Adobe Stock licensed image by motortion

          Reflections on Boris Johnson’s ‘high skill, high wage future’ speech: the invisible half of the population

          Official United Kingdom Parliamentary photographs 2020 Tom Randall (politician) - CC-BY-3.0

          Why do people become MPs?

          Image by Central Bylines Team - derived from eligible Creative Commons sources

          Gaslighting an electorate – the moral bankruptcy of Edward Leigh 

          Adobe Stock licensed: Gibberish
by egokhan

          Lucy Allan talks gibberish

          Image by Number 10 for flickr licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 2.0

          Red wall voters to Johnson: in the name of God, go!

          Say no to the elections bill

          Say no to the Elections Bill

          Trending Tags

          • Lifestyle
            • All
            • Art
            • Books
            • Dance
            • Festivals
            • Fun & Games
            • Movies
            • Music
            • Poetry
            • Sport
            • Theatre
            • TV
            Image by author

            Anne Boleyn

            Portrait of William Byrd by The Trustees of the British Museum ©, licensed by CC BY-NC-SA 4.0

            William Byrd – “a Father of Musick”

            Waverly community garden

            Launch of Better Together Community Garden in Clayton

            Illustration by AB Wyze

            Here I’m sat

            Liverpool in Paris

            Gun Control

            ‘Gun Free Zone’ (a ‘Found’ poem, extracted from Trump’s NRA conference speech in Houston, a few days later)

            Bally Gill, David Morrissey, James Graham and Joanne Froggatt - sherwood cast

            Sherwood: what lies beneath?

            O'Rourke

            O’Rourke

            Fighter,Pilots,Cockpit,View,Under,Cloudy,Blue,Sky

            Top Gun, I feel the need…..

            Trending Tags

              • Dance
              • Food
              • Music
              • Poetry
              • Recipes
              • Sport
            • Business
              • All
              • Economy
              • Technology
              • Trade
              cloudy beer

              UK’s first cloudy beer

              Cost of living crisis

              Crisis? What crisis? The cost of living crisis and political responses

              Adobe Stock licensed image by hanohiki

              Bad news for Newark: 110 jobs lost as town’s top employer withdraws to the EU 

              Promotion image from Colleague Box website

              Pandemic start-up success story hampered by Brexit barriers

              Image licensed by Pixabay

              Information is power: its loss can be devastating

              Photo by Matt Bango on StockSnap

              Hassle in High Peak: Robert Largan’s solar farm shenanigans

              Adobe Stock licensed - image by blackday

              British Gas-lighting a nation: how energy companies are exploiting their customers with increased prices

              circular economy

              Reflections on Boris Johnson’s ‘high skill, high wage future’ speech

              Dog wrapped in a blanket, luckily he does not have to pay the bill.

              Fuel bills and service blunders as energy prices start to bite

              Trending Tags

              • Levelling up
              • Economy
              • Technology
            • Region
              • All
              • East Midlands
              • West Midlands
              Image by Number 10 used under CC2 - Prime Minister Boris Johnson met Irish Taoiseach Leo Varadkar on 10 October 2019 to discuss the UK's Brexit proposals.

              The Northern Ireland protocol

              Waverly community garden

              Launch of Better Together Community Garden in Clayton

              Rent seeking

              A ‘high skill, high wage future’? Rentier capitalism: who owns the future?

              Liverpool in Paris

              Mark Serwotka

              Trades unionists demand action on the cost-of-living crisis at rally in Stoke-on-Trent

              East midlands greatest hits

              East Midlands Conservative greatest hits, Spring 2022

              Allens Cross Community Centre

              St Bart’s Pantry, open for business!

              women in power 2

              Women in power

              Vera Brittain plaque

              Midlands blue plaques part 1: Vera Brittain in Buxton

              Trending Tags

                • East Midlands
                • West Midlands
              • Events
              No Result
              View All Result
              Central Bylines
              No Result
              View All Result
              Home UK

              For Argument’s Sake: Taking Dominic Cummings’ Tweets Seriously

              How seriously should we take Cummings' comments on the UK and Northern Ireland Protocol. Did they sign just to get brexit done?

              John CotterbyJohn Cotter
              16-10-2021 09:49
              in UK
              Image by Stephen118 from Pixabay

              Image by Stephen118 from Pixabay

              Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
              ADVERTISEMENT

              When the front page of the Sunday Telegraph appeared on Saturday the 9th of October to proclaim, “Johnson faces fresh Brexit clash with Judges”, it seemed to portend a wearisome week ahead. And so it has proved, with Tuesday seeing David Frost’s Lisbon speech, and Wednesday the EU’s proposals to deal with issues concerning the implementation of the Northern Ireland Protocol. In the midst of all this, there was a noticeable escalation of the usual Brexit culture war being waged permanently on social media.

              Into this virtual cacophony stepped Dominic Cummings, who in a string of characteristically bombastic and chaotic tweets, made claims which were either revelatory or mundanely confirmatory depending on how jaded you are. In perhaps the most interesting of these Cummings asserted, referring to the Protocol, “… we wriggled thro with best option we cd & intended to get the [trolley emoji] to ditch bits we didn’t like after whacking Corbyn.”

              We took over a party on ~10%, worst constitutional crisis in century, much of deep state angling for BINO or 2REF. So we wriggled thro with best option we cd & intended to get the ? to ditch bits we didn't like after whacking Corbyn. We prioritised. Now time for IM2 #Frosty

              — Dominic Cummings (@Dominic2306) October 12, 2021

              It should be noted that there are many reasons not to take Cummings’ tweets seriously. For one, in a possible contradiction in terms he wears his Machiavellianism openly. One can extrapolate from Cummings’ own account that constraints like international law or values like good faith will not provide obstacles to him in advancing his aims. He also appears to have departed on bad terms with Boris Johnson to whom he routinely and rather evocatively refers as ‘the trolley’ (hence the emoji). A narrative that Cummings was a strategic genius undone by his bumbling political squad led by captain Johnson is naturally self-serving.

              Nevertheless, I am going to make a highly problematic working assumption and take Cumming’ tweets at face value.

              If Cummings’ tweets do represent the truth of what happened in late 2019, they would confirm a belief long held by many that those in power (or close to power) in 10 Downing Street made a decision to sign (or urge the signature of) the Withdrawal Agreement, including that key Northern Ireland Protocol, simply to enable Johnson to run his ‘get-Brexit-done’ election campaign. The intention, according to Cummings in a subsequent tweet, was to then jettison the more unpalatable aspects of the Protocol by legislating away the domestic legal effect of such aspects via the Internal Market Bill.

              A cynic might point to the fact that politicians exaggerate or even lie as a matter of course around election time. That, however, would be to equate more prosaic political matters like more tax and spending adjustments with what the Northern Ireland Protocol represents. The decision to leave the EU placed a stress on the Good Friday Agreement and the arrangements underpinning it, which enabled people living in Northern Ireland to look one way, towards Ireland or towards Britain, or both ways; both in identity and in commerce.

              The purpose of the Good Friday Agreement was also to build a political process through which political claims and aspirations could be pursued on as sustainable and stable a basis as possible. Brexit as of and by itself, and the uncertainty in the aftermath of the referendum presented major challenges. Once a decision was taken that Britain would leave the European customs union and single market, and it was determined that Mrs May’s UK-wide backstop was unacceptable, the options, in terms of attracting greatest consensus and least disruption in Northern Ireland, narrowed.

              Johnson was essentially stuck between a no-deal Brexit, which would have necessitated goods checks on the Irish border (impractical, highly disruptive, and completely unacceptable to Nationalists and Republicans), or what he chose in the end (with its implications for the UK union). The economic ‘both ways’ situation that had persisted prior to Brexit could not continue in the same completely uninterrupted manner. There would be some checks on goods moving from Great Britain to Northern Ireland.

              However, Northern Ireland would be in the enviable economic position of having access to the European single market and the UK internal market. From the two narrow and less-than-ideal options available at the very end, the Protocol seemed by a distance the least disruptive and the most sustainable. All of this would depend of course on both the EU and UK keeping their bargain and acting in good faith.


              More from Central Bylines

              • Brexit means sour grapes for UK wine lovers
              • Does Britain have the cheapest food in Europe?
              • EU haulage firms now avoiding the UK

               Cummings’ tweets demonstrate a contempt for both concepts if they serve to obstruct him. The electoral and international relations deception described by Cummings therefore was no mere puff or grey lie: it demonstrated a duplicitous preparedness to agree at haste and then unilaterally unpick at leisure the very instrument designed to best ensure the sustainable continuation of the economic conditions that underpinned the Good Friday Agreement.

              A cynic might also assure us (indeed Cummings did himself) that states break international law all the time, so casting aside uncomfortable aspects of the Protocol would hardly be remarkable. For one, that others may break international law from time to time is hardly a justification. Moreover, a distinction must be made between breaches of more technical international agreements and an agreement designed to protect a peace process.

              It should also be recalled that many Brexiteers heralded Brexit as the beginning of an age of ‘Global Britain’ in which the UK would use its newly acquired independent trading competence to complete deals nimbly with economies around the world. Trust and good faith are, however, essential to such endeavours, especially in the age of post-gunboat diplomacy.

              States will be more likely and will be faster to complete agreements with the UK where trust exists, something with which Cummings’ anti-law, bad-faith, cheating-foreigners philosophy is at odds. It may well be that observers around the world will view the Northern Ireland Protocol and the British government’s behaviour around it as exceptional and confined to a highly specific and contentious constitutional question, rather than representing its entire approach to international law and relations.

              However, if anyone out there has, apart from for the purposes of this exercise, taken Cummings’ tweets seriously, then they cannot have helped convince anyone of the UK government’s bona fides.

              ADVERTISEMENT
              Previous Post

              Brexit means sour grapes for UK wine lovers

              Next Post

              Sir John Hayes wages anti-woke war on the National Trust

              John Cotter

              John Cotter

              Related Posts

              Gates of Downing St
              Covid

              No excuses Boris. Most people obeyed  lockdown rules

              byEdward Cartwright
              24 April 2022
              Photo by RODRIGO GONZALEZ on Unsplash
              Covid

              The challenges faced by long covid sufferers as we “learn to live” with covid

              byKelly Heath
              23 April 2022
              LFT positive test
              Covid

              Covid-19: millions of families lose their freedom as Boris Johnson gives some lives priority over others

              byJune Roche
              7 March 2022
              Image by Number 10 for flickr licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 2.0
              Opinion

              Red wall voters to Johnson: in the name of God, go!

              byCentral Bylines Team
              4 February 2022
              Author's own image
              A Cotswold Diary

              The Hillsborough disaster and the Sheldon Tapestries

              byAnn C Holland
              12 January 2022
              Next Post
              Photo by Ann Girolami

              Sir John Hayes wages anti-woke war on the National Trust

              Want to support us?

              Can you help Central Bylines to grow and become more sustainable with a regular donation, no matter how small?  

              DONATE

              Sign up to our newsletter

              If you would like to receive the Central Bylines regular newsletter, straight talking direct to your inbox, click the button below.

              NEWSLETTER

              LATEST

              Protester

              Roe v Wade: men benefit from abortion rights too – and should speak about them more

              28 June 2022
              Power to the people

              Power to the people

              28 June 2022
              Image by Number 10 used under CC2 - Prime Minister Boris Johnson met Irish Taoiseach Leo Varadkar on 10 October 2019 to discuss the UK's Brexit proposals.

              The Northern Ireland protocol

              27 June 2022
              Image by author

              Anne Boleyn

              27 June 2022

              MOST READ

              Protester

              Roe v Wade: men benefit from abortion rights too – and should speak about them more

              28 June 2022
              Patriotism in the UK

              Johnson isn’t a patriot, he’s a pariah

              24 June 2022
              Andrew Ward

              The government is doing massive damage to farming

              10 January 2022
              Image by Number 10 used under CC2 - Prime Minister Boris Johnson met Irish Taoiseach Leo Varadkar on 10 October 2019 to discuss the UK's Brexit proposals.

              The Northern Ireland protocol

              27 June 2022

              BROWSE BY TAGS

              Blue Plaques Climate change Community Cost of living crisis Covid Energy Farming Johnson Latest Levelling up My Little Town Rwanda Ukraine Conflict Voting Whistleblower
              Central Bylines

              Central Bylines is a regional online newspaper that supports citizen journalism. Our aim is to publish well-written, fact-based articles and opinion pieces on subjects that are of interest to people in Central England and beyond.



              Learn more about us

              No Result
              View All Result
              • Contact
              • About
              • Donate
              • Privacy policy
              • Bylines network
              • Back Editions
              • Shop

              © 2022 Central Bylines. Citizen Journalism | Local & Internationalist

              No Result
              View All Result
              • Home
              • News
                • Brexit
                • Education
                • Environment
                • Health
                • Transport
                • World
              • Politics
              • Back in the news
              • Opinion
              • Lifestyle
                • Dance
                • Food
                • Music
                • Poetry
                • Recipes
                • Sport
              • Business
                • Economy
                • Technology
                • Trade
              • Regional Events
              • Donate
              • Newsletter sign up
              • A Cotswold Diary
              • Authors
              • BYLINES NETWORK
              • Contact

              © 2022 Central Bylines. Citizen Journalism | Local & Internationalist

              Welcome Back!

              Login to your account below

              Forgotten Password?

              Retrieve your password

              Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

              Log In
              X